In Vehicle IP, LLC v. Werner Enterprises, Inc., C.A. No. 10-503-SLR (D. Del. Oct. 1, 2013), the jury returned a verdict finding that plaintiff had not proved that defendant’s system infringed the asserted claims of the patent in suit and that defendant had not proved that the same claims were invalid due to lack of enablement. Prior to trial, Judge Robinson precluded defendant from arguing at trial an untimely raised invalidity theory, and an untimely raised non-infringement theory. Prior to trial, Judge Robinson also granted summary judgment of non-infringement as to certain claims.