Last week, Judge Robinson granted a motion to stay pending re-examination in Vehicle IP, LLC v. Wal-Mart Stores, Inc., C.A. No. 10-503-SLR (D. Del. Nov. 22, 2010). Citing the September decision in Belden (which denied a motion to stay pending re-examination just before trial), the Court applied a simple three-factor test to determine that a stay is warranted in light of the status of the litigation and the lack of prejudice to the parties. One footnote cited re-examination statistics showing that the average appeal to the patent board takes 234 days, plus an additional 15 months to appeal that determination to the Federal Circuit.
Of note, the Court stated that “[i]f, after six months, the court is not satisfied that the reexamination is moving at a pace whereby reexamination will provide a resolution as promptly as would be otherwise achieved through this litigation, the court may lift the stay.” Vehicle, at 5.